Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Expand
titleVirtual meeting 2017-06-14

ATTENDEES: Wendy, Dan G., Jay, Larry


Review of revised collection pattern as found in NewCollectionPattern

  • There is the idea of a collection and then that a collection is made up of a structure
  • Base collection (abstract) then specializes to a unordered, strictorder, orderrelation.
  • There is the collection which can be of 3 types - but we want a means of describing the entirety of the
  • Too much stuff in the base class - separate the thing from the underlying structure
  • What we want is a name of the whole collection just at the root
  • A "proposed collection" that then related to information about the collection and then that contains the structures
  • Creates a bag of bags as an entry point to the collection


Move from BaseCollection to NewCollection

  • type 1..1 CollectionType Binary choice of Bag or Set
  • name 0..n Name A linguistic signifier. Human understandable name (word, phrase, or mnemonic) that reflects the ISO/IEC 11179-5 naming principles. If more than one name is provided provide a context to differentiate usage.
  • purpose 0..1 InternationalStructuredString Explanation of the intent of this collection. Supports the use of multiple languages and structured text.
  • usage 0..1 InternationalStructuredString Explanation of the ways in which some decision or object is employed. Supports the use of multiple languages and structured text.

Add to NewCollection

  • (make a note that this SHOULD be realized as AnnotatedIdentifiable)
  • isDefinedBy points to base collection which is the root bag
  • [totality, semantics, hasRelationSpecification]
  • class by definition is the master collection


Follow-up from Lawrence KS..who's working on what:

  • Jay..ppt continuing (waiting on realiztions to complete) - what happens to realizations of the process pattern
  • Jay..beginning to see of the work Chifundo's doing as a means of road testing some of the pattern stuff we're doing
  • Larry..will work on examples when test realizations are done
  • Dan..probably has something outstanding and will work on test realizations


Related work:

  • Qualitative and custom should be cleaned up (Dagstuhl)
  • Dan is working on LIM


Expand
titleVirtual meeting 2017-06-07

ATTENDEES: Wendy, Jon, Jay, Oliver, Dan, Larry
Issues from Lawrence

  • DMT-134 resolved - in review
  • DMT-133 resolved - in review
  • DMT-132 documentary, Oliver will clarify process and add to documentation of bindings (also need to add to property documentation - use of name "content"

Collection Pattern:
Singletons

  • A singleton is a bag so we can pick an element; one thing that we were throwing around was the idea of having a shortcut representation of where your domain would be a bag. Our language is such that it is really talking about a single thing to a bag.
  • If its easier to do this by pointing to a member than to a singleton bag. Worry about the representation when we get there.
  • If you have something that is pointing to an object and you want it to another object
  • Proposed collection example: what elements in the range are the target of the relationship
  • Larry's hierarchy issue of breaking relationships
  • One of the advantages we have here is that we are talking about a pattern, so in talking about specific realizations we need to realize in a way that prescribes its usage which say forces them to use a parent/child or part/whole relationship
  • The proof will be when we start looking at realizations
  • We need to think about what it means to have a relationship to the relationship to the specific items or to the items in the inner relationships - clarify this in documentation
  • The domain of the inner relationship should be the target of the outer relationship
  • Hierarchies are created a level at a time (if transitivity applies all the way through you're OK, if not, this could be an issue)


Layout for work this summer (prep for Codebook development review)

  • Oliver: August all
  • Dan: August most
  • Jon: end of July and all of August
  • Larry: teaching in June in afternoons
  • Jay: generally available
  • Wendy: July 19th

ACTION: Wendy will review work and draft summer work plan and send out for comment

...