You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.
Compare with Current
View Page History
« Previous
Version 2
Next »
Interoperability for Cross-Domain Research workshop: FAIR Vocabularies ("Down Under Dagstuhl")
Virtual: 27th September-1st October 2021
Participants (incl Organizers)
Amir Aryani - Swinburne University
Natalia Atkins - IMOS / AODN
Jason Atkinson - Australian Bureau of Statistics
Irina Bastrakova - ICSM / Geoscience Australia
Michael Biddington - Australian Bureau of Statistics
Susan Birtles - Resources QLD / Permanent Committee on Place Names
Rowan Brownlee - ARDC
Adrian Burton - ARDC
Nick Car - Surround Australia / ANU
Edmond Chuc - TERN / UQ
Simon Cox - CSIRO
Anu Devaraju - Terrestrial Ecosystems Research Network
Kheeran Dharmawardena - DAWE
Armin Haller - ANU / W3C
Michael Lawley - CSIRO / Australian e-Health Research Ctre
Mark Lindsay - CSIRO Minerals
Jenny Long - Geoscience Australia
Steven McEachern - ANU
Doug Palmer - CSIRO / Atlas of Living Australia
Shawn Ross - FAIMS / Macquarie University
Sandra Silcot - Indigenous Data Network
Len Smith - ANU / IDN
Simon Wall - National Library of Australia
Megan Wong - Federation University / Nat. Cttee on Soil and Terrain
Lesley Wyborn - ARDC
Workshop Meeting Details
The workshop is organised into 5 rooms consisting of a Plenary room - Dungeon, and four breakout rooms - Chateau, Maligava, Palace, Schloss.
Direct link to Zoom room
- Plenary room: Dungeon
- Backup Plenary room: Use this if Plenary room doesn't work for any reason Backup Dungeon
- Breakout rooms:
- Château (Simon)
- Maligava (Steve)
- Palace (Rowan)
- Schloss (Lesley)
Password for room: dagstuhl21
Workshop Shared Whiteboard
The workshop will be utilising this Miro board.
Workshop Shared Folder
The workshop resources and shared documents are available on this Shared Drive.
Workshop Agenda
Monday 27th September 2021
Framing the work |
|
Time |
Item |
10:00
Plenary - Dungeon |
Opening
- Welcome - Simon Cox (5 min)
- Workshop plan - Steve McEachern (10 min)
- Intros & icebreaker - Kheeran Dharmawardena (30 min actual)
|
10:45
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 1
Vocabulary examples
- ANZSCO - Jason Atkinson (slides) (25 min)
- SNOMED - Michael Lawley (slides) (25 min)
|
11:40 |
Bio break |
11:50
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 2
Vocabulary examples
- Place Names - Susan Birtles (slides) (20 min)
- Indigenous names - Sandra Silcot/Len Smith (slides) (20 min)
|
12:45 |
Break 1 (Lunch) |
13:30
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 3
Vocabulary examples
- Follow-up discussion and questions (15 min)
FAIR vocabularies
- Intro to FAIR - Rowan Brownlee (slides) (5 min)
- 10 simple rules - Simon Cox (slides) (10 min)
- Follow-up discussion and questions (15 min)
|
14:15
Plenary - Dungeon
then Breakouts |
Session 4
Working session
- Nominate and select vocabularies to be FAIRified - Kheeran
- Sort participants into breakout rooms - Kheeran
- Collaboratively begin case-studies
Rooms:
Chateau - AS4590
Maligava - Munsell Colours
Palace - Historical Police Districts
Schloss - GBIF Taxon
|
15:30 |
Break 2 |
15:45
Plenary - Dungeon |
Evaluation and wrap-up - Lesley |
16:00 |
Close - Day end |
Tuesday 28th September 2021
Wednesday 29th September 2021
Deliverable 2: Best practices guidelines for governing, managing and using FAIR vocabularies |
|
Time |
Item |
10:00
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 1
Opening (10 min)
- Welcome - Simon Cox
- Plan for the day - Kheeran
Vocabulary technical publication
- Introduction to Research Vocabularies Australia - Rowan Brownlee (15 min)
Vocabulary governance and use
- Getting people to use governed vocabularies is hard - Shawn Ross (15 min)
|
11:30 |
Bio break (15 mins) |
11:45
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 2 - governance, maintenance and use
- It is so hard to use vocabularies - Steve McEachern (10 min)
- TERN vocabulary maintenance guidelines - Anu + Edmond
- Maintenance of dynamic vocabularies - Michael Biddington
|
12:30 |
Break 1 (Lunch) |
13:45
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 3 - Keynote
Perspectives on vocabulary governance:
- SNOMED governance - Michael Lawley
|
14:00
Plenary - Dungeon
then
Breakouts |
Session 4
Preparing for working sessions
- Governance considerations template - Simon
- Sort participants into topics and breakout rooms
Working Session
|
14:50 |
Break 2 (15 min) |
15:05
Breakouts |
Session 5
Working Session |
15:45
Plenary - Dungeon |
Wrap up - Organisers |
16:00 |
Close - Day end |
Thursday 30th September 2021
Deliverable 2: Best practices guidelines for governing, managing and using FAIR vocabularies
Deliverable 3 (optional): A specification for the FAIR vocabulary technical framework |
|
Time |
Item |
10:00
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 1
Opening (5 min)
- Welcome - Simon Cox
- Plan for the day - Kheeran
Discussion on challenges from yesterday (15 min)
- Place types (Palace)
- AS 4590 (Chateau)
- Munsell colours (Maligawa) approved
Vocabulary technical platforms
- Technology survey - Edmond (10 min)
- Ontoserver - Michael Lawley (15 min)
|
11:20 |
Bio break (10 mins) |
11:30
Plenary - Dungeon |
Vocabulary technical platforms (cont…)
- Vocabulary APIs - Nick Car (15 min)
|
12:05
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 2
Perspective on vocabulary applications
- Vocabulary applications/data integration - Amir Aryani
|
12:30 |
Break 1 (Lunch) |
13:30
Plenary - Dungeon
then
Breakouts |
Sessions 3a - governance
Working session - wrap up templates - edit/add to the LHS
- Maligava - Rowan/Lesley - consolidate Munsell
- Chateau - Simon - shift to ANZSCO
- Palace - Steve - carry-on with place-types
Sessions 3b - technical framework
Working session - technical
- Develop a grid of tools/platforms, what does what well?
- Schloss - (e.g. MichaelL, Nick, Edmond, Doug, Adrian)
|
14:45 |
Break 2 (15 min) |
15:00
Plenary - Dungeon |
Discussion on challenges
Bringing it all together
- Kheeran's landscape analysis
- How do we bring it all together - Steve/Simon
|
15:45
Plenary - Dungeon |
Wrap up |
16:00 |
Close - Day end |
Friday 1st October 2021
Consolidation, writing, emergent themes
Potential deliverable 4: Guideline for adoption of a vocabulary - what is a trusted vocabulary? |
|
Time |
Item |
10:00
Plenary - Dungeon |
Opening (15 min)
- Welcome - Simon Cox
- Plan for the day - Kheeran
Options for the day:
- 10 Simple Rules for FAIRification - write up 'Different pathways from different starting points' - e.g. compare Munsell & AS 4590
- Master template
- Munsell colours
- AS 4590
- Administrative areas
- Police districts
- GBIF Taxon names
- Governance concerns - consolidate the templates (and compare SNOMED, ANZSCO?)
- Master template
- Munsell colours
- AS 4590
- ANZSCO
- Place types
- SNOMED (TBC)
- Tech tools catalogue/grid
- Catalogue of vocabulary tools
- Trust/Sustainability - new topic? -
- CoreTrustSealthis covers FAIR + Gov concerns and TRUST Principles
- Patterns for vocabulary re-use, networks of vocabularies, views & subsets
|
10:30
Breakouts |
Session 1+
Working session - …
- Maligava - Governance concerns
- Chateau - Trust
|
11:45 |
Bio break (15 mins) |
12:00
Plenary - Dungeon |
Session 2
Announcements - future events
|
https://www.rd-alliance.org/get-involved/individual-membership.html] as an individual: membership is free
|
https://www.rd-alliance.org/plenaries/rda-18th-plenary-meeting-virtual/moving-toward-vssig-20]Moving toward VSSIG 2.0
-
- ARDC-coordinated Australian Vocabulary Special Interest Group (AVSIG)
- Coordinated by Rowan and chaired by Megan and Natalia.
- Is an information sharing group, not a working group
- Meets quarterly (should it meet more frequently?)
- Sign up and join here
Where to next for DUD:
- Which of this week's activities will continue?
- eResearch Australasia 2021
- Governance concerns - Anu, Kheeran & Simon report to eRA
- Implementation - Tech grid - Nick? report to eRA
- Trust … Shawn & Steve report to eRA
- Topics from this week
- Munsell - will be built! RIT involved in governance (Shawn leading)
- Place names will continue within the ARDC HASS program (Len, Sandra and Steve) ARDC-led
- Link to ARDC Geospatial COP?
- Exploring MoU with ICSM and ARDC
- Explore other infrastructures as well as RVA
- New topic of interest (have been recognised as needed to be done by Big Brother Dagstuhl (as opposed to DUD)):
- Different approaches to reusing, extending or subsetting - another 'template', or set of 'rules' or 'concerns' -
- Who: Simon, Rowan, Nick, Edmond, Sandra, Susan, Mark - to investigate a starting point
- Where: To be determined.
- Vocabulary creation ?
- Meet again in a year's time?
- Should it be a week-long activity again?
- Yes if possible
- Virtual or F-2-F or Hybrid (a mix of both)
- Allow blocks of time to work on stuff raised at the meeting - less intense.
- I found starting at 10:00 am and finishing at 4:00 helpful
- 2 days f2f kick-off and then the rest virtual?
Sandra: Appreciation to the organisers for setting it up, and managing the evolving agenda
|
13:00 |
Close |